India could ban private cryptocurrency: why?

India could ban private cryptocurrency: why?

Credit: Swarajya

The “Banning of Cryptocurrency & Regulation of Official Digital Currency Bill, 2019” has been listed on the official Department of Economic Affairs website.

An Indian government inter-ministerial committee (IMC) has recommended that “cryptocurrencies created by non-sovereigns” should face a total ban.

The report states that all private cryptocurrencies except ones issued by the government will be banned in India, declaring any activities related to cryptocurrencies as a criminal act. The committee consisted of the Secretary (Economic Affairs) as the chairman, along with the Secretary, ministry of electronics and information technology, SEBI chairman and the deputy governor of the Reserve Bank of India.

The report, along with a draft bill, was submitted to the government on Monday. The IMC report and the draft bill will be reviewed before action is taken; the report claims that there are around 2,116 cryptocurrencies with a market capitalisation of $119.46 billion.

“The Committee notes with serious concern mushrooming of cryptocurrencies almost invariably issued abroad and numerous people in India investing in these cryptocurrencies. All these cryptocurrencies have been created by non-sovereigns and are in this sense entirely private enterprises,” the report says.

According to the committee, cryptocurrency cannot serve the same purpose as traditional fiat currency. “The private cryptocurrencies are inconsistent with the essential functions of money/currency,” the report claims, “Hence private cryptocurrencies cannot replace fiat currencies”

Why are some people so sceptical of cryptocurrency?

Centuries ago, we traded possessions. Gold, silver and other precious metals were swapped from person to person before coins were formed from these metals. Next came notes, which were significantly lighter, meaning that buyers and sellers could trade large amounts of money without needing to transport it.

Eventually, “fiat money” – “Let it be done” in Latin – was introduced. Governments began controlling legal tender, determining its worth and enforcing laws stating that printing your own currency was illegal, as it diluted the structure already in place. Exchange rates were set between differing currencies – either floating exchanges or fixed – in order to let citizens swap from one kind of money to another.

The invention of money predates written history. This timeline is important when considering cryptocurrency’s role in the history of the currency as a whole. Money has had intrinsic value for centuries and though we no longer make pound coins out of solid gold, our currencies are centralised and regulated thoroughly. This is where cryptocurrency comes in.


There’s no denying that value is evolving. Physical assets are still worth money, but digital assets are increasing in worth too.


The report recently published in India is particularly critical of decentralised currencies and it is not alone in its fear. There are many who misunderstand the concept of decentralisation and assume that if, for example, Facebook introduces a cryptocurrency, it’s Facebook issuing the money on that platform.

“There is no underlying intrinsic value of these private cryptocurrencies. These private cryptocurrencies lack all the attributes of a currency. There is no fixed nominal value of these private cryptocurrencies i.e. neither act as any store of value nor they are a medium of exchange,” the Banning of Cryptocurrency & Regulation of Official Digital Currency Bill, 2019, states.

Simply, your fiat bank account is backed by your bank. Your bank is regulated by the government. If your bank is hacked, you will receive your money back. If your bitcoin were to be hacked, there’s no back-up.

Is banning cryptocurrency a good thing?

Sceptics aren’t just lining up on one side to oppose crypto. There are those that believe that institutions’ deep distrust of digital currencies suits their stronghold of the status quo and the existing structures in place by the establishment.

“The divine line ‘Bitcoin/Cryptocurrency is for criminals’ is a cunning defensive strategy created by [the] so-called traditional financial services sector,” Mohith Agadi, Founder of CEO of Cryptobond, once claimed.

Regardless of whether banks and governments have an ulterior agenda when it comes to banning digital currency, there’s no denying that value is evolving. Physical assets are still worth money, but digital assets are increasing in worth too: the world’s top five companies are all technology-based and have data as a primary asset.

[forminator_poll id=”2336″]

Cryptocurrencies can be a stable way to store value and where they differ strongly to fiat money is that their values are not determined by any kind of action from a government or local economy. Before the global financial crash in 2008, for example, the pound rocketed from $1.40 to $2.10 in October 2007, in just five years. Independent cryptocurrencies don’t have to be intertwined with the growth of a country: this is good news for citizens in countries with a weak national fiat currency.

Whilst experts can disagree about the promise of crypto, however, blockchain and the idea of decentralisation is beginning to capture the imagination of businesses. Cryptocurrency is still an evolving innovation; a new infrastructure technology could emerge from blockchain and potentially revolutionise the way we think of digital value, just as digital value has transformed our concept of physical value.

Luke Conrad

Technology & Marketing Enthusiast

How E-commerce Marketers Can Win Black Friday

Sue Azari • 11th November 2024

As new global eCommerce players expand their influence across both European and US markets, traditional brands are navigating a rapidly shifting landscape. These fast-growing Asian platforms have gained traction by offering ultra-low prices, rapid product turnarounds, heavy investment in paid user acquisition, and leveraging viral social media trends to create demand almost in real-time. This...

Why microgrids are big news

Craig Tropea • 31st October 2024

As the world continues its march towards a greener future, businesses, communities, and individuals alike are all increasingly turning towards renewable energy sources to power their operations. What is most interesting, though, is how many of them are taking the pro-active position of researching, selecting, and implementing their preferred solutions without the assistance of traditional...

Is automation the silver bullet for customer retention?

Carter Busse • 22nd October 2024

CX innovation has accelerated rapidly since 2020, as business and consumer expectations evolved dramatically during the Covid-19 pandemic. Now, finding the best way to engage and respond to customers has become a top business priority and a key business challenge. Not only do customers expect the highest standard, but companies are prioritising superb CX to...

Automated Testing Tools and Their Impact on Software Quality

Natalia Yanchii • 09th October 2024

Test automation refers to using specialized software tools and frameworks to automate the execution of test cases, thereby reducing the time and effort required for manual testing. This approach ensures that automation tests run quickly and consistently, allowing development teams to identify and resolve defects more effectively. Test automation provides greater accuracy by eliminating human...

Custom Software Development

Natalia Yanchii • 04th October 2024

There is a wide performance gap between industry-leading companies and other market players. What helps these top businesses outperform their competitors? McKinsey & Company researchers are confident that these are digital technologies and custom software solutions. Nearly 70% of the top performers develop their proprietary products to differentiate themselves from competitors and drive growth. As...

The Impact of Test Automation on Software Quality

Natalia Yanchii • 04th October 2024

Software systems have become highly complex now, with multiple interconnected components, diverse user interfaces, and business logic. To ensure quality, QA engineers thoroughly test these systems through either automated or manual testing. At Testlum, we met many software development teams who were pressured to deliver new features and updates at a faster pace. The manual...